Skip to Content

Our Commitment to Truth

Exposing falsehood demands more than conviction. It requires evidence, honesty, accountability and the willingness to be corrected.

The Biblical Foundation

Proverbs 18:17 - "He that is first in his own cause seemeth just; but his neighbour cometh and searcheth him."

The proverb recognises a fundamental problem in human judgement: a claim may appear convincing until it is examined from another perspective. Scripture does not encourage believers to accept accusations simply because they are forcefully presented. It calls for truthful testimony, fair judgement and careful consideration. These principles must govern our own investigations as much as those of anyone we criticise.

Read Proverbs 18

The Question Before Us

How can readers know whether an investigation is exposing deception or merely presenting another persuasive version of events?

A publication may quote genuine documents while omitting inconvenient passages. It may reproduce accurate statistics but draw unsupported conclusions. It may expose a real mistake while falsely accusing someone of deliberate dishonesty. This page explains how we intend to evaluate claims, distinguish evidence from interpretation, represent opposing arguments and correct our own errors.

Examine Our Editorial Standards

The Difference Between Error and Deception

Not every false statement is a deliberate lie. A person may misunderstand a document, rely upon inaccurate information or draw a conclusion that later evidence disproves. Deliberate deception involves an intention to mislead, which may be difficult to establish without additional evidence.

This distinction is especially important when examining named individuals and organisations. We should not accuse someone of knowingly lying merely because their statement is inaccurate. Likewise, an unverified allegation must not be presented as an established fact. Our editorial language should reflect the strength of the evidence.

Primary Sources Before Repeated Claims

Whenever possible, investigations should begin with original material. For a religious movement, this may include official doctrinal statements, sermons, books and organisational publications.

  • For a historical event, it may include contemporary records, inscriptions, correspondence and archaeological reports.
  • For a scientific claim, it may include peer-reviewed research, methodological documentation and relevant datasets.
  • For political controversies, it may include legislation, court decisions, official transcripts and complete recordings.

Secondary commentary can provide valuable context, but repeating a claim across numerous websites does not make it independently verified. Ten articles repeating the same unsupported allegation remain one unsupported allegation.

Fairly Representing Opposing Positions

An argument becomes easy to defeat when it has first been distorted. A Christian criticism of another denomination should identify the doctrine actually taught by that denomination. A discussion of evolution should accurately describe contemporary evolutionary biology rather than attacking an outdated caricature. An investigation into political policy should distinguish the stated purpose of a law from its demonstrated effects and any unproven claims about hidden intentions.

We may reject an argument after examining it. But we do not misrepresent it to make rejection easier.

Deception in Practice - When Publications Fail Their Own Standards

Case Study 1 - The Rolling Stone University of Virginia Article

In 2014, Rolling Stone published an article alleging a gang rape at the University of Virginia. Serious failures in verification and reporting subsequently emerged. The magazine retracted the article, and the Columbia Graduate School of Journalism produced an external review of the journalistic failures.

The episode illustrates the danger of allowing a compelling narrative to replace independent verification. It also demonstrates why corrections must be visible and why serious allegations require particular care.

Case Study 2 - The Piltdown Man Forgery

The Piltdown case also offers a lesson about institutional credibility. The forged remains were accepted by some prominent researchers, partly because they appeared to fit certain expectations. Later scientific examination exposed the fraud. The appropriate lesson is not that all scientific findings are unreliable.

It is that even respected institutions require methods capable of detecting and correcting error.

Our Corrections and Review Policy

Every substantial investigation should display its original publication date and latest review date. Where an article contains a material factual error, we should correct the text and explain the change. Minor typographical corrections need not become public announcements. But significant changes affecting the meaning or conclusion of an article should be documented.

Where a serious allegation concerns an identifiable person or organisation, reasonable efforts should be made to obtain and accurately represent their response. A correction should not be hidden merely because it weakens a preferred argument.

Beyond the Church - Why Should You Trust a Christian Publication?

You should not accept our conclusions simply because we quote Scripture. If you do not share our religious convictions, the distinction between theological claims and verifiable factual claims becomes particularly important. We can explain why Christians believe Scripture is authoritative.

But a claim about a modern court case, archaeological discovery or scientific measurement must still be supported by appropriate evidence. Readers should be able to identify where biblical interpretation begins and where independently verifiable information ends.

What Have We Established? - Standards Must Apply to Everyone

The pursuit of truth requires consistent methods. We cannot demand primary evidence from opponents while relying upon rumours that support our own position. We cannot condemn misleading quotations while removing context from statements we dislike.

And we cannot claim that correction is a virtue while refusing to correct ourselves. Our editorial standards should be regarded as commitments against which readers may hold us accountable. The strongest evidence of our commitment to truth may not be the arguments we win, but the mistakes we are willing to acknowledge.